Banning religion undermines secularism

Quebec wants to ban elementary school students from wearing religious symbols, too.

"State neutrality means that the state must neither encourage nor discourage any religious conviction whatsoever."

The Quebec government has already banned public sector employees from wearing religious symbols and restricted prayer in workplaces and public spaces. Now, it wants to ban elementary school students from wearing religious symbols, too.

The Parti Québécois government has pledged to extend the province’s laicity laws during the province’s recent election. After forming a minority government, education minister Joël Arseneau reiterated that commitment.

The move has already attracted significant opposition from the National Council of Canadian Muslims, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, and academics, as well as the opposition Liberals and Québec Solidaire. The Québec Conservatives have suggested they might support the policy, however.

There is nothing “secular” about dictating what a person can or cannot wear, or whether they may pray in a public park. This is state coercion, pure and simple.

We should no more tolerate these attacks on religious freedom than we would opening a public school with the Lord’s Prayer, telling every graduate to “use their degrees for the glory of god” or requiring newly elected politicians to swear an oath on the Bible.

As BCHA wrote in Lost in Translation, “Quebec’s model of laicity attempts to assert a collective right to the appearance of a secular state.” Instead of promoting a open and multicultural secularism, Quebec is transforming neutrality from abstention into coercion.

Lost in Translation
Bushfield, I. et. al. (2026 April 15). “Lost in Translation: From Laicity to True Religious Neutrality.” BC Humanist Association.

This is why we do not translate laïcité as secularism but as laicity. There is a critical distinction here as true secularism, or religious neutrality as the Supreme Court of Canada referred to it, requires abstention. The government should neither be favouring nor hindering any religion or belief.

Yet, through its actions, we see the Government of Quebec do just that. It invokes laicity to justify the suppression of individual religious expression.

With the Canadian Secular Alliance earlier this year, BCHA intervened at the Supreme Court of Canada’s case over the constitutionality of Bill 21 – Quebec’s previous religious symbols ban. Our arguments centred on the individual nature of the right to religious freedom and the importance of religious neutrality.

Our factum also points out the impracticality of the government’s claim that it can dictate whether any particular symbol is religious rather than simply cultural. This issue is obviously not solved by increasing the number of people a religious symbols ban applies to.

This new proposal is a direct attack on the rights of the children of Quebec and the value of religious neutrality. It sows division at a time when solidarity has never been more critical.

Humanism is a non-religious worldview: we reject infallible revelations. However, humanists are not anti-religious. We stand for individual liberty and human rights. We support secularism, defined as the absence of state religious coercion, as it protects our (and everyone’s) freedom to believe or not whatever belief system we choose.

Nothing about banning “religious” symbols upholds these values.

Ian Bushfield speaks at a podium. Credit: Humanist International
Executive Director at BC Humanist Association | + posts

Ian Bushfield is the Executive Director of the BC Humanist Association. He lives in Coquitlam, BC.

Share the Post:

Related Posts